CEE Assessment@JCU Assessment Case Studies Challenges Using Blogs, Vlogs and Podcasts
Challenges Using Blogs, Vlogs and Podcasts
- 69蹤獲
- JCU Global Experience
- International Students
- Open Day
- How to apply
- Pathways to university
- Virtual Open Day
- Living on Campus
- Courses
- Publications
- Scholarships
- Parents and Partners
- JCU Heroes Programs
- Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander in Marine Science
- Elite Athletes
- Defence
- AI@JCU
- Current Students
- New students
- JCU Orientation
- LearnJCU
- Placements
-
CEE
- Search
- About CEE
- Education Strategy
- Teaching@JCU Support
- Assessment@JCU
-
TEL Design
- About LearnJCU
-
Assessment & Feedback
- Artificial Intelligence
- Assessment Tools
- Assessing Group Work
- Assessment Case Studies
- Assessment Methods
- Enable or Disable Submission View
- Inline Marking
- Grade Centre Setup
- Group Assessment Tools
- Marking and Feedback
- Multiple Choice Questions
- One Question at a Time
- Peer Review
- Release Conditions
- Respondus Secure Online Exams
- Respondus FAQs
- Safe Assign
- Save Grade Centre Filtering
- Submission Receipts
- Test Response Download
- Test Settings
- Timezones
- Video Assessment
- Collaboration
- Communication
-
Content & Learning Resources
- Accessibility in LearnJCU
- Banners for Subjects
- Computations
- Content Management
- Create Studio
- Emojis in Ultra Docs
- Exemplars in LearnJCU
- H5P in LearnJCU
- Hypothesis
- Intro Videos
- Learning Sequence (PDF)
- LearnJCU Layouts (PDF)
- Digital Media Support
- LinkedIn Learning
- Mayer's 12 Principles of Multimedia (PDF)
- Media Resources
- Open and Licensed Resources
- Padlet in LearnJCU
- Panopto Video Capture
- PebblePad ePortfolios
- Progress Tracking
- Release Conditions
- Subject Site Setup
- Organisation & Structure
- Participation & Engagement
- The Learn Lowdown
- Endorsed technologies
- Data & Evaluation
- Student Success
-
Development & Recognition
- JCU L&T Conference
-
Professional Development
-
Grants & Awards
- JCU Learning & Teaching Innovation Grants
- JCU Sessional Teaching Awards
- JCU Inclusive Practice Awards
- JCU Inclusive and Accessible LearnJCU Site Awards
- JCU Citations for Sustained Commitment to Enhancing Diversity, Equity and Inclusion
- JCU Citations for Outstanding Contributions to Student Learning
- National Citations for Outstanding Contributions to Student Learning
- JCU DVC Education's Student Experience Award
- Showcasing Excellence
- Communities of Practice
- Unicare Centre and Unicampus Kids
- Graduation
- Off-Campus Students
- JCU Job Ready
- Safety and Wellbeing
- JCU Prizes
- Professional Experience Placement
- Employability Edge
- Art of Academic Writing
- Art of Academic Editing
- Careers and Employability
- Student Equity and Wellbeing
- Career Ready Plan
- Careers at JCU
- Partners and Community
- JCU-CSIRO Partnership
- Alumni
- About JCU
- Reputation and Experience
- Chancellery
- Governance
- Celebrating 50 Years
- Academy
- Indigenous Engagement
- Education Division
- Graduate Research School
- Research and Teaching
- Research Division
- Research and Innovation Services
- CASE
- College of Business, Law and Governance
- College of Healthcare Sciences
- College of Medicine and Dentistry
- College of Science and Engineering
- CPHMVS
- Anthropological Laboratory for Tropical Audiovisual Research (ALTAR)
- Anton Breinl Research Centre
- Agriculture Technology and Adoption Centre (AgTAC)
- Advanced Analytical Centre
- AMHHEC
- Aquaculture Solutions
- AusAsian Mental Health Research Group
- ARCSTA
- Area 61
- Lions Marine Research Trust
- Australian Tropical Herbarium
- Australian Quantum & Classical Transport Physics Group
- Boating and Diving
- Clinical Psychedelic Research Lab
- Centre for Tropical Biosecurity
- Centre for Tropical Bioinformatics and Molecular Biology
- CITBA
- CMT
- Centre for Disaster Solutions
- CSTFA
- Cyclone Testing Station
- The Centre for Disaster Studies
- Daintree Rainforest Observatory
- JCU Eduquarium
- JCU Turtle Health Research
- Language and Culture Research Centre
- MARF
- Orpheus
- TESS
- JCU Ideas Lab
- TARL
- eResearch
- Indigenous Education and Research Centre
- Estate
- Work Health and Safety
- Staff
- Discover Nature at JCU
- Cyber Security Hub
- Association of Australian University Secretaries
- Services and Resources Division
- Environmental Research Complex [ERC]
- Foundation for Australian Literary Studies
- Gender Equity Action and Research
- Give to JCU
- Indigenous Legal Needs Project
- Inherent Requirements
- IsoTropics Geochemistry Lab
- IT Services
- JCU Webinars
- JCU Events
- JCU Motorsports
- JCU Sport
- Library
- Mabo Decision: 30 years on
- Marine Geophysics Laboratory
- Office of the Vice Chancellor and President
- Outstanding Alumni
- Pharmacy Full Scope
- Planning for your future
- Policy
- PAHL
- Queensland Research Centre for Peripheral Vascular Disease
- Rapid Assessment Unit
- RDIM
- Researcher Development Portal
- Roderick Centre for Australian Literature and Creative Writing
- Contextual Science for Tropical Coastal Ecosystems
- State of the Tropics
- Strategic Procurement
- Student profiles
- SWIRLnet
- TREAD
- TropEco for Staff and Students
- TQ Maths Hub
- TUDLab
- VAVS Home
- WHOCC for Vector-borne & NTDs
- Media
- Copyright and Terms of Use
- Australian Institute of Tropical Health & Medicine
- Pay review
Claire Hansen and - Challenges using blogs, vlogs and podcasts for assessment in a first-year English Literature subject.
In this JCU snapshot, we consider an innovative subject, designed to give students the opportunity to express themselves in different digital modalities, to make their own choices and to access good amounts of formative feedback.
While the assessment design was promising, the subject coordinators felt the assessment was not as effective as they hoped. This snapshot provides an overview of their design and the challenges they experienced.
Valid; Fair; Authentic; Continuous; Transparent; Varied methods
Subject | EL1009 Great books: Epochs and Classics |
---|---|
Study Mode | Internal and External |
Campus | Townsville and Cairns |
Coordinator | Claire Hansen and Roger Osborne |
Courses | Bachelor of Arts, Bachelor of Education |
The aim of this subject is to provide students with an engaging journey through the works of major authors and texts of English Literature.
The coordinators designed an assessment task whereby students created vlogs (video blogs), blogs, or podcasts to express their critical thoughts, to develop their digital writing skills in multiple modalities and to interpret the ‘great books’ that form the basis of study in this subject.
Additionally, their continuous assessment strategy was intended to provide students with opportunities:
for guidance (scaffolding) in the way of informal, formative, summative and global feedback.
to interact with other students in their classes and those studying online or at another campus.
Students are mainly BA or BEd students with a few international exchange and Psych students.
Students who successfully complete this subject will be able to:
Identify the characteristics of a selected text in the context of a major literary period and movement.
Apply the method of close reading to the analysis and interpretation of set texts.
Communicate and have an understanding of the interpretation of literary texts through the production of analytical and argumentative writing; and apply a complex understanding of one set text within its literary movement and period.
Blogs/ Vlogs or Podcasts (30%)
- Students write two blogs (750 words) or record two vlogs (video blogs) or a podcast (3 mins) between week 1-7 on a chosen text and post to a WordPress site that has been created for the subject.
- Students are encouraged to make their posts engaging to readers/ viewers/ listeners through the use of images, graphics, videos and links.
- Students are also encouraged to respond to each others’ posts.
- Finally, students collate their blogs/vlogs/ podcasts into one Word document and submit to LearnJCU for marking.
This assessment task was designed, not only to help students complete their readings and provide feedback in various forms, but also to help students practise applied research skills thereby strengthening their capacity to complete the final essay for the subject.
Additionally, this assessment task provides an opportunity to develop multimodal communication skills and familiarity with contemporary digital communication platforms.
In implementing this assessment strategy, there were a number of challenges the subject coordinators raised about the effectiveness of the assessment design.
Challenge 1: Getting the right balance of blogs/vlogs/podcasts
- In the initial implementation, students had to complete 3 blogs/vlogs/podcasts, however this became difficult to manage for students and with increasing student numbers so it was reduced to 2 blogs/vlogs/podcasts in the second year.
Challenge 2: Too many choices for students
Students had choices around the weeks and thus readings they chose to respond to in their blog/vlog/podcast.
The subject coordinators felt they gave students too much choice and too many moving deadlines for their stage of study (first-year).
Challenge 3: Students confused around submission dates
As due dates were determined by the weeks they chose for their readings, each student had their own unique due date which caused confusion.
Students often left it a little late to get started and got a bit confused about dates – despite clear instructions and guidance provided.
There were multiple due dates students needed to manage – for example there was an additional due date to submit their portfolio of blogs to the LearnJCU platform that was the same for all students. Students had difficulty managing all of these dates.
Challenge 4: Student engagement
The subject coordinators believed that students would feel more accountability for their work as they were sharing it with other students – however this did not equate to student engagement for all students. Posting responses to other students’ work was not compulsory, but encouraged, however, many students didn't engage with the opportunity.
External students in particular were less engaged – the subject coordinators were unsure of students’ expectations of engagement for an external online subject.
Although there are many opportunities for guidance, checkpoints, feedback and continuous assessment, the reading workload was quite high and while some students readily engaged while others were more ‘resistant readers’.
Challenge 5: Students’ digital literacies
- Some students got a little confused working with Wordpress (a blogging platform) and related platforms (e.g. YouTube, Sound Cloud) which highlights some issues with students’ digital literacy levels.
Challenge 6: Workload for the teaching team
Due to confusion about due dates, there were many student queries to staff.
Staff had to be aware of students’ unique deadlines to manage submission dates and apply late penalties were relevant.
The next iteration of the assessment task
The subject coordinators are now using online quizzes to add more checkpoints to ensure readings are completed. This also means students are writing on a broader range of texts. Quiz questions are also shorter and more targeted which is more manageable and clearer for first year students.
This revised approach has mitigated the need for student queries to staff (because there is no confusion on due dates). At the same time, the quizzes are designed to engender more engagement with the readings across the semester. However, this approach also comes with constraints in terms of fostering more creative approaches for expression and collaborative knowledge-making.
In addition, due to Covid-19, in 2020 this subject is running online-only, which means another assessment task (Assessment 3: Proposal Presentation) now requires the use of technology for recording and publishing a presentation that is usually given live. Reducing the technological requirements of Assessment 1 balances this in a more manageable way for students.
WordPress
YouTube/ Sound Cloud
Storymap JS
JS Story
LearnJCU
For first-year students, try to ensure that due dates are fixed and clear.
Choices around assessment can be powerful but sometimes students just need clarity, especially in first year.
Consider levels of digital literacy when selecting technologies and consider the staff time/workload to teach the chosen platforms.
Consider the time commitment necessary to complete the tasks for both students and staff.
Assessment Community of Practice (CoP)
If you would like to be involved in a community of practice focused on investigating assessment in higher education, follow the link to 'Communities of Practice' to find out how to join.